|
|
![]() Helping San Diego, California and beyond since 1997.
|
|
Click here and add this page to your favorites!

"God's High Calling for Women"
by
1 Timothy 2:11
Part 3
John MacArthur
All Rights Reserved
(A copy of this message on cassette tape may be obtained by
calling 1-800-55-GRACE)
Let's open our Bibles together to 1 Timothy chapter 2--1 Timothy chapter
2. A couple of weeks ago I was reading a very interesting biographical sketch
of a rather famous family. Some of us remember the name Beecher as a family in
American history. Surely you know the name Harriet Beecher Stowe, a great
American novelist. Harriet Beecher Stowe was one of thirteen children. The
oldest member of the family was Catherine(?) Beecher, she was the oldest of the
thirteen. She was one of nine children by her mother and there were four other
children born to a step-mother whom her father married after her mother had
died.
Catherine Beecher particularly grew up having a natural love for children.
She found great joy in the duties of raising children. She loved to care for
infants. She loved to care for little children. When Catherine was only 16,
and all of the rest of the children born to the mother, nine of them, were
younger than she was, her mother died. So she was left really to mother eight
other little children.
Her mother had been very skilled in domestic hand craft and spent a great
amount of time teaching Catherine how to take care of the home. And so she was
quite good at that by the age of 16.
Into the home came an aunt and the aunt was to be the replacement for
mother. And the aunt was remarkable for her neatness and her order and her
ability to deal with things on an economical basis. Later on, she was replaced
by a step-mother who was expert in all matters of administration in the home.
Under them all, Catherine--with experience and the tutelage of these women--by
the age of 23 had learned all that was to be learned about domestic life and
decided that the state of women in the United States was so severe that she
needed to do something very dramatic to train women for domestic
responsibility.
So, she founded the Hartfort(?) Female Seminary, the design of which was
to train women to be lovers of their husband, lovers of their children and
keepers at home. She and her sister, Harriet Beecher Stowe, not only founded
the Hartfort Women Seminary but a couple of years later they founded the same
thing in Cincinnati, Ohio with the view to training women for domestic
responsibility.
At that same time, around 1869, they wrote a book entitled The American
Woman's Home. Let me read you just a little of it. "Women's calling embraces
the care and nursing of babies in those critical periods of infancy and
sickness--the training of the minds of children in the most impressionable
years of life, childhood. It involves the matter of meeting the needs of her
husband so that his life is enriched and his home a haven. It involves the
responsibilities of the economy of the house for the benefit of family and all
others who grace it. These duties are as sacred and demanding as any given to
man. Yet, where is her preparation? And what body certifies her as duly
prepared to give the best to her calling?" End quote.
As a result of that desire to give to women training so that they could be
capable at their domestic responsibility, they founded the two seminaries and
they wrote this as their purpose, "The purpose is to teach women how not only
to perform in the most approved manner all the manual employments of domestic
life, but to honor and enjoy them."
Now the reason I read you that is just to kind of give you a little idea
of how far we have come in a few years. The cigarette commercial that said,
"You've come a long way, baby," is indeed true. If anybody imagined to start a
female seminary to train women today in domestic responsibility, they would
become the instant laughing stock of the whole United States...if not most of
the world. It would be absolutely bizarre for anyone to attempt to gain
society's approval for such an effort. Can you imagine the kind of ridicule
that would come upon someone for doing that? To endeavor to train women to be
lovers of their husband, lovers of their children and keepers at home would put
a person in direct opposition to everything that's happening in human society.
By the way, such a seminary, or such training similar to that seminary is
the goal of the Master's College and soon you'll be hearing about our emphasis
in that area. We are in a day today when role reversal is really high priority
for Satan. It would be one thing if it was occupying itself with the world,
but it is even more tragic when it occupies itself with the church. And the
church today has definitely lost its sense of perspective and balance in terms
of what a woman's role is to be. I'm amazed month by month to see more and
more traditional evangelical Bible believing people begin to change their view
of the woman's role under the pressure of the society around them. The sad
part is that they are then instructing women to deny a God-given and a
God-ordained pattern for life which would bring them the highest joy. And
that's sad.
It was a problem in the day of Catherine Beecher, it's a problem today and
I would like to add it was a problem in the day when Paul wrote his first
letter to Timothy. And as you look at 1 Timothy chapter 2 verses 9 through 15,
you will note that Paul is dealing with that very problem. He is identifying
here a problem of women who were asserting themselves and trying to overtake
the role of men in the church. They were acting indecently in the church.
They were acting shamefully. They were violating their God-ordained place,
defying the divine standard. And so Paul writes to Timothy encouraging him
with this corrective in verses 9 to 15 to set things in order in the church at
Ephesus where Timothy is located at the present time. So, they had their own
problems in that time as we have the problem in this time.
Now in verses 9 to 15, a very concise passage, there are seven verses
there but they're very brief with the exception of verse 9, so there really
aren't a lot of words here, but in a very few words there is a very
comprehensive treatment of the role of women. That's why it's going to take us
the past two weeks, this week and at least one more to get through these verses
because they open up to us such a wide-range of understanding that must be
explored in order to get the full teaching of Scripture. But in these brief
verses there is a presentation of six elements related to a woman's place in
the church. Now we're not talking about the home here, we're not talking about
secular society here, we're just talking about the church. In fact, we're
talking about the church when it comes together to worship. We're talking
about the order of the church, behavior in the church.
These six elements with which Paul deals are their appearance, their
attitude, their testimony, their role, their design and their contribution.
And he emphasizes all of these things in a way that is sort of building to a
climax that comes in verse 15 which we'll look at next week. And I'm telling
you, I can hardly wait. It's so wonderful.
But let's be reminded in verse 9 of their appearance. "In like manner,
also, that women adorn themselves in proper apparel with godly fear and
self-control, not with braided hair, or gold, or pearls, or expensive
clothing." Now the first thing that occupies the mind of Paul, as we saw a
couple of weeks ago, is that women are to dress in such a way that they are fit
for worship. They are dressed in such a way that they draw attention to their
devotion to God and not to themselves. They are not to flaunt their sexuality.
They are not to flaunt their wealth. They are not to flaunt an attitude of
insubordination to their husbands. They are not to make other people look at
them with envy. They are not to create sexual enticement in other men. All of
these things are bound up in what we saw in verse 9. Their appearance is very
very important. Obviously some women were coming together in the assembly of
the redeemed saints and calling attention to themselves for their own passion's
fulfillment and their own selfish desires.
Secondly, we looked at their attitude. Their attitude was to be one of
godly fear. That word really has as its root the idea of a sense of shame.
They are to have a proper shame about themselves. That doesn't mean a woman is
to be ashamed of herself. That doesn't mean she's to be ashamed of her beauty
and hide it. What it means is she is to have a sense of shame that says I
would never want to do anything to cause someone else to be illicitly
attracted. I would never want to do anything that would cause someone else's
attention to be drawn away from God to me. Her attitude is one of a sense of
shame, that she should ever be the cause of someone else's sin.
Secondly, self-control...and the word is related to controlling her
desires and controlling her passions and not being in a position to cause
others to have wrong desire. So, their appearance then ought to be fit
worship, and their attitude as well.
Thirdly, their testimony in verse 10 is a part of his discussion. A woman
who professes publicly godliness should prove that confession with good works.
So, you have not only appearance and attitude but you have her action, or her
activity. That which she does, that which she says should indicate the
legitimacy of her claim to godliness.
Now those three then brought us to the fourth, and we're going to look at
it again today, and that is their role. And now you come to the real heart of
this text in verses 11 and 12. The role of the women is given in these words,
"Let the women learn in silence with all subjection, but I permit not a woman
to teach nor to usurp authority over the man but to be in silence."
Now you will notice that verse 11 begins with being in silence and verse
12 ends with being in silence. And so that brackets the whole idea here and
becomes the dominant thought. The dominant thought is that when the church
comes together for worship, the women are to be in silence. And in the middle
of that he sort of speaks to that very issue.
Now as we looked at this role of women given by God and created in women
by His creative power, we first of all and last week emphasized the opening
statement of verse 11, "Let the women learn." And I hope you understood the
major point that I was making is that on the spiritual level men and women are
equal. They're equal. And as a result of that, they are equally entitled to
be involved in the learning process. And we suggested to you that there were,
no doubt, people in the church at Ephesus who came out of a Jewish background
or people in that church who came out of a Greek background, both of which
diminished the role of women, both of which held that women were inferior and
both of which would assume that it wasn't important or even necessary that
women learn anything. And so this, no doubt, had filtered into the church and
Paul is saying let the women learn. Let them--manthano is the verb, we get the
word "disciple" from it--let them be disciples, let them be learners, let them
be in on the process of grasping understanding and applying divine truth. And
don't let the influence of Jewish culture or Greek culture which diminishes and
denigrates the role of women speak evil of them and hinder them from learning
the truth of God.
And we went to the Old Testament, you remember, and I told you that the
law was given for men and women. And the rules about the Passover were given
for men and women. And God personally appeared to both men and women. And the
service of God involved both men and women. You come to the New Testament, and
men and women serve the Lord. And men and women are responsible for all the
commandments. And they are given all the promises. And they are promised all
the blessings. And they are warned about all the curses. In other words, in
terms of spiritual life and blessing, all are equal. There's no question about
that.
But that does not mean that their role is the same. You can have
spiritual equality and have all different roles. To put it another way, you
and I are spiritually equal. You and I have the same spiritual responsibility
before God to live to His glory, is that not so? We have the same
responsibility to obey the Word of God, the same responsibility to pray and to
teach the Word of God and to witness and to live a Christlike life and we have
the same promise of blessing, we have the same fruit of the Spirit, we have the
same hope of eternal life. On the spiritual level, we're all equal and yet
obviously in a role situation, you're there and I'm here.
And we should be comfortable with equal spirituality and differing roles.
I don't know why we want to make a battleground out of that. For all the
women to demand to have equal roles with men would be like all the congregation
demanding to have equal roles with the one who's preaching, and you can
understand what that would do. These are just roles that God has designed for
us to play to fulfill His will.
So, we see then Old Testament and New Testament equality of spiritual
life. But we do not see equality of role. And you remember, as we looked at
the Old Testament last time, I told you that there were no women priests, none.
There were no women holding on-going prophetic office. There were some women
who were called a prophetess, namely four of them, the wife of Isaiah was only
called a prophetess because she was going to give birth to a child whose name
had prophetic meaning, not because she said anything. But Miriam, Deborah and
Huldah are all three called prophetess and all we know about them is that each
of them in the Bible is recorded on one occasion to have given a message from
God. We don't know that they had any on-going prophetic ministry,
certainly not like the major prophets, the minor prophets, Elijah, Elisha,
Moses. We have no such woman leaders.
Deborah appears in the list of judges in Judge 4:4 to have been in a
position of giving some wise counsel in the life of Israel. But she is far and
away the exception and we really don't know when and how and how many times she
was used by God to give wisdom. There are no women kings in all the history of
Israel. And somebody would no doubt ask me what about 2 Chronicles 22:12 where
it says, "Athaliah reigned..." It does not call her king or queen,
Athaliah--you'll remember--was the mother of Ahaziah. When he died she wanted
to rule, so she massacred the entire royal seed. The only one she didn't get
was Joash, you remember, he was protected and later became the king. But she
usurped that throne and was not and is not to this day listed among the kings
of that land.
No woman kings, no woman priests, no woman with on-going prophetic office.
Ruth and Esther are named after
women but were not written by women. So they had no on-going role of
leadership in the normal course of life, in God's economy in the Old Testament,
though some of them were used by God here and there to speak a word for God and
many women prophesied, according to Psalm 68, a great host are the women who
published the good news. That doesn't mean that women couldn't speak for the
Lord. Of course not, they should speak for the Lord. But they were not given
the roles of leadership within the nation of Israel either in political life or
religious life, both of which were the same in a theocracy rule by God.
You come to the New Testament and you remember that there's neither male
nor female in Christ, Galatians 3:28. And we know we're all equal spiritually
and yet it's very obvious in the New Testament, there are no women apostles.
Although there were women who accompanied Christ and the twelve, they are not
included in the twelve. There are no women prophets. There is Anna mentioned
in Luke 2 and said to be a prophetess because her husband had died seven years
after their marriage and she for over 80 years had stayed in the temple waiting
for the Messiah. And anyone who came in the temple she would tell them about
the Messiah coming and what a joy it was when she met the Messiah even as an
infant. But she really is a hold over from the Old Testament and she was a
prophetess in the sense that she spoke about the Messiah to anyone who came
along.
And then you look in the New Testament again and you do see that the four
daughters of Philip did prophesy, they did speak for God but a lot of women
speak for God. We don't know anything about it, they're not called prophets.
That would be after the church began and they're not called prophets, it just
says they prophesied, they spoke forth for God is implied there. There were
other women, 1 Corinthians 11, we'll get back to that in a minute, who also
prophesied, spoke forth for God, but as I said, there are no women apostles, no
women called prophet, evangelists, pastor-teacher, elder.
So, both Old Testament and New Testament make it clear that though there
is equality on the spiritual level, there are differing roles. And all of that
was just a review of what I gave you last week, so if you want the fill in on
that, get last week's message and you'll have all of it.
But that equality of learning which is given here in verse 11 is qualified
at the end of the verse. Let's go back to it and I want to speak the rest of
the time this morning on the last half of verse 11. "Let the women learn," and
here comes the qualifier, "in silence with all subjection...in silence with all
subjection.
Now you have to understand what's going on in the culture to get an idea
of what's going on in this situation. Now remember that you have in the church
at Ephesus a Gentile culture as the basic culture in which the church exists.
Asia Minor which is modern Turkey was a Gentile place. And women were ranked
in Gentile religion very low...very low. In fact, if you were to go to the
temple of Diana of the Ephesians in Ephesus, you would find hundreds and
hundreds of priestesses there called "melasi(?)" whose primary function was to
act as prostitutes for the male worshipers. They were chattel. They were to
be used and discarded.
Furthermore, any respectable Greek woman who was not some kind of
prostitute, some kind of street walker led a very confined life. She lived in
her own quarters into which no one but her husband could enter. She had not
even the privilege of appearing at a meal unless she was invited to be there.
She never at any time appeared on the street alone. She never went to any
public assembly. And still less did she ever speak or take any active part in
an assembly. So you can understand that when some of these women were
converted, boy, they began to feel their oats--to put it in the colloquial
expression. And they would read that concept that we understand, male and
female equal as one in Christ, and they would say, "Boy, we're going to take
our place now." Other women were coming out of a Jewish background. We know
that because there are indications in 1 Timothy that there were Jewish
influences in the church at Ephesus.
So here you have some women coming out of a Jewish background which was
very much the same terms of suppressing women and keeping them in a sort of
deprived situation in terms of learning, and now these women have come to faith
in Jesus Christ, perhaps in some cases they're growing faster than their
husbands, and so they too begin to feel the surge of the desire for prominence
and to get out from under this abusive kind of chauvinistic tradition that they
have known. And so there's pressure applied in the church as these women begin
to assert themselves. Now you add to that that this church was a sinful church
and there are not only those pressures that come because these women are
overreacting to their liberty in Christ, but you add the sinfulness of the
culture around them which obviously would militate against the things of God
and you've got loose and immoral women in the church who are coming to church
flaunting their sexuality, flaunting their wealth, trying to entice and allure
other men. You've got women who are trying to surge into positions of teaching
and surge into positions of leadership, women who don't want to subordinate
themselves to their husbands anymore, they want to take over the authority in
the church, the authority in the relationship at home. And the church is in
great great need and great great danger.
And so, as chapter 3 verse 15 says, this whole section is to set things in
order in the church. The second thing he wants to set in order after the
prayer passage in verses 1 to 8 is this matter of the role of the women because
it's all out of whack. And he calls, basically, for them to learn in silence
with all subjection.
Two things there, they are to be silent and subject. The word "silence"
means just that, hesuchia, it just means silence. We have to define what that
is intended to say by the context. The word "subjection" is from hupotasso
which means to line up under. In other words, to get in their proper line and
not rebel. They're not to be unruly, they're to get in line in their proper
place. So women are to learn in silence and get in line in their proper place.
Now it's obvious the Bible says that, no one's going to equivocate on
that. It says let the women learn in silence. Well, you say, "What are people
who believe in women preachers going to do with this?" Well, they're going to
take the word "silence" and they're going to say it doesn't mean that. Silence
means a meek and quiet spirit. What it means is that when you do preach or
teach, you do so in a quiet spirited way. All right. There are those who want
to advocate that.
There are others on the other hand who are hard line and they say when it
says let the women learn in silence, that's exactly what it means. No women
should ever talk in church under any conditions...not into the person they're
sitting next to, not on the way in, not on the way out...you know, the real
hard line thing...total silence. Women never give a testimony. Women never
pray. Women never speak...nothing.
Now which of these two or what other option do we have? The answer is
very simple. You always define terminology by context. And all you have to do
is look at the context to figure out exactly what he means by silence. Verse
11, "Let the woman learn in silence with all subjection." What do you mean,
Paul? I mean, I don't permit a woman to...what?...teach, that's the silence
issue. Nor usurp authority, that's the subjection issue. He defines exactly
what he means.
What he means by the silence of a woman is that he does not permit a woman
to take the role of teacher. What he means by her subjection is he does not
permit her to rise to usurp authority over men in the life of the church. He
doesn't mean that the woman can't sing a song. He doesn't mean that in an
appropriate place the woman cannot pray a prayer. He does not mean that she
cannot offer praise to God at an appropriate time. It does not mean that she
cannot participate in worship, it doesn't mean that she can't even ask a
question when a question is called for in a proper spirit and a proper way.
What it means is she is not to be the teacher and she is not to rebel against
the role of submission which God has designed for her in the life of the
church.
So, silence then is in relation to teaching. And it means she's not to be
the teacher. We'll get into that in more detail next week as we see what the
phrase in verse 12 actually means. The subjection is easily understood to mean
she is not to rebel, she is not to desire to overturn the divine pattern.
Now we need to understand what this means. Let's...okay, we've got the
church, we're looking at the church, we're saying, "All right, a woman is not
to be the teacher." That's plain and simple, we're not to have preachers and
teachers standing up in church before everyone, mixed congregations of men and
women who are the official teacher of the church and the official preacher,
giving the message, the sermon, the lesson. That's right, that's very obvious.
But there are other passages that broaden our understanding of this and we
need to look at them. So let's go back to 1 Corinthians chapter 14 and you're
going to find this, I think, very very interesting. In 1 Corinthians 14:34 we
have a very similar statement to a very similar situation. In verse 34 it
says, "Let your women keep silence in the churches." Now it isn't too hard to
figure out what that means. You do not have to be a Greek scholar. It is
obvious what it means. And in case you missed it, let the women keep silence
in the church, I love this kind of reasoning, for it's not permitted to them to
speak. And you say, "Well, wait a minute, that's just saying the same thing
twice without a reason." No, that is the reason. The reason women are to keep
silent in the church is because it isn't permitted for them to speak. You say,
"That doesn't give me a reason." Sure it gives you a reason. They are
commanded to be under obedience so also says...what?...the law. The law of
who? The law of God.
Do you know why women aren't to preach in the church? You say, "Well, it
has to do with their psychological..." No...no. "Well, it has to do with the
fact that, see, if you give a woman that kind of role, if she doesn't have the
mentality to deal with the things that come a...." No, no, the reason they
don't do it is because God's law says they can't do it, that's all. That's the
issue. It's not sociological, it's not psychological, it's not pathological,
it's not anything, it's just the law of God. So, women are to keep silence in
the church.
You say, "Well, what does that mean?" So now we have a big debate about
what it means to be silent again. Well, let's find out what it means. It
shouldn't be too hard, all we have to do is look at the context. So we go back
in the chapter a little bit and we ask ourselves, "What is this chapter all
about?" Well, verse 1 of chapter 14 talks about prophesying. Verse 2 talks
about tongues. And then you have tongues and prophesying compared all the way
through the chapter. And he says that of course the best thing is to prophesy.
Verse 39, you don't want to stop speaking in languages legitimately. In that
apostolic age it was a legitimate gift of God. But it's better that you should
desire as a congregation when you come together that prophesy be done, that's
the proclamation of the Word of God. And most of all, verse 40, it ought to be
done decently and in order.
But you want to get an idea of what's going on there? Let me give you
some background. Right across the bay from Corinth is another city. The name
of that city is Delphi. In the city of Delphi there is a religious structure.
At the pinnacle of this religious structure is a woman by the name of
Pythia(?). She is known as the "Oracle of Delphi." Have you ever heard that
phrase? She is known as the "Oracle of Delphi" in this very time. At the
height of Delphic religion there were three such priestesses. The dominant one
that we know of in history is Pythia, this from Stuart Rossiter(?) in his book
on Greece in which he treats this whole thing. This is a woman about 50 years
of age and she is a medium who contacts demon spirits. She is the astrologer,
star gazer, prognosticator, fortune teller, palm reader of her time. And
everybody wants to know the future and everybody wants to know what it holds
and everybody wants to know the secrets and everybody wants to know how things
are going to turn out and they want to know how to get rid of their problems
and so forth and so forth. And so everybody wants to go to get to the "Oracle
of Delphi" to give them the truth. So it is a very popular religion.
Controlled, of course, by Satan and run through demons who speak through this
medium and she gives out this stuff.
Now Rossiter in describing this tells us some very interesting things.
Someone who goes over there, first thing they have to do is make an animal
sacrifice. It can be a sheep, a goat, a bear or some other animal. They make
an animal sacrifice while a few attendant priestesses stand around and evaluate
the omens and the sacrifice. I don't know how they did that...maybe had to do
with the way the thing burned or the way the inside of the animal fell, some
kind of omen.
If the omens were favorable based on the evaluation of the sacrifice, the
person could then come into the inner shrine. No woman could ever be admitted
into that, only men. So the man would come in, let's say the omens were good
so they accepted his sacrifice so the man comes in. He takes a tablet and on
that tablet he writes his request. By the way, archaeologists have dug up that
area and found some of those tablets still in tact. So we know some thing
about what the people were asking. That tablet then as he waits in line is his
consideration to be given to the oracle. And finally if all fortune goes well,
he is ushered into the oracle. She is sitting on a tripod, three legs going
rather high over a huge chasm from which rises incense smelling heavy dense
smoke. And she's sitting over this chasm to answer this request.
Before she can take her throne, she has to be bathed in the castallian
fountain. She has to eat laurel leaves and she has to go through some kind of
thing. And she gets up there and the request is taken and presented. In
response to the request, she gushes out some absolutely inarticulate babble,
some kind of demon talk. Standing beside her is a poet who interprets
everything she says in perfect hexameter, which is a poetic form. And that is
the interpretation because nobody understands what she's saying. And the
person then hears a very obscure, very confusing hexametric poetic bunch of
babble from this guy that probably leaves them more confused than they were
when they got there. But they have had an ecstatic experience and they've
encountered the supernatural.
Now think about that. That's right across the bay from Corinth. Now in
the church at Corinth, and Satan always counterfeits something that God does,
if God has a true gift of languages and a true gift of interpretation, and a
true gift of prophesying and speaking forth the Word of God, then Satan's going
to move in as close as he can and counterfeit the whole thing. And so you've
got some people coming to the Corinthian assembly and what they're doing is
mediamistic occultic demon kind of stuff, they're uttering these same babbles
that came out of the mouth of the Delphic Oracle and the same kind of obscure
nonsensical prophetic things that are coming over there and they're doing it
supposedly in the name of Christ and the church...some people in the church are
doing the true gifts and the people in the church are not rightly evaluating it
and what you've got in Corinth is absolute confusion. Some people actually
standing up, claiming to have the gift of tongues, cursing Jesus Christ and
being patted on the back for it because it must be of God because it's
supernatural. Now that's the background of 1 Corinthians.
Anybody is absolutely naive who comes into chapter 14 and starts reading
about tongues and prophesy and doesn't have that as background. Paul is
correcting all of that. So the issue here in the Corinthian church was not
only that there were women who were flaunting their sexuality, they were in
Corinth. We know there were terrible sex in the Corinthian church, wasn't
there? Terrible sexual evil. But here you have some women who are looking at
a religion that is all women, the Delphic thing, and saying, "Boy, we ought to
be prominent in this religion, too." So they're pushing themselves into
prominence by standing up and speaking in this unintelligible babble by
standing up and giving their prophecies. So when we come to this chapter, look
at verse 26, he says, "What is going on with you? When you come together,
everyone of you has a psalm, a doctrine, or a teaching, a tongue, a revelation,
interpretation, let everything be done decently and in order." Get this messed
straightened out.
And then he says no more than two or three people in tongues, never
without an interpreter. Don't let the prophets speak except two or three of
them, and everybody evaluate them to see if they really know the Lord, they
really speak the truth. Get this thing together, verse 33, because God is not
the author of what? Confusion. And then in verse 34 he says let the women
keep silent. Keep silent about what? Well, it's obvious. Speaking publicly
in the assembly of the church either in ecstatic speech or prophecy. So if we
look at 1 Timothy, we see women are not to preach or teach. If we look at 1
Corinthians 14:34 and 35, we can conclude very simply women are not to speak in
tongues and women are not to give prophecies in the church. They are not to
speak forth in the church. Why? It's not permitted. Why? They're to be
under obedience. Why? The law of God says that.
Here it comes. "It is indecent for women to speak in the church." It's
not indecent for women to speak, you can speak all you want...unless you're
usurping the role of authority, unless you're taking leadership in the church.
This is so clear. So, what are we saying then? When it comes to the meeting of the church
together, women are not to preach or teach, they are not to speak forth the
Word of God and they are not to speak in ecstatic speech. Obviously, the sum
of those things is to say that the church when it comes together is to be
spoken to by men. That's just God's way.
But the underlying thing that I want you to understand here is this, this
does not mean that a woman can never under any circumstances speak in a group
of Christians. What this speaks to is the women who usurp that, who push
themselves in the place of prominence. Remember, God used Miriam to speak a
word for Him. God used Deborah and Huldah to speak a word for Him to very
important men. God used Anna for scores of years in the temple, speaking of
the coming Messiah to anybody who came there. So there's no reason to believe
that on the right time and the right place woman can't speak. When Paul
traveled on his trips through the book of Acts it says that he went into an
area to a church and he dialogio, he dialogued with them out of the scriptures,
I believe there were men and women, I believe honest questions could be asked
by women in right format and could be answered by the Apostle Paul. I think
there was a time and place for women to speak a testimony of phrase to the
Lord. I don't think that he's saying that they can never do that. What he is
saying is they cannot rise to leadership in the church so that they become the
ones who dominate the church with their authority and their teaching and their
gifts. There is a place, of course, when it is the right environment and we
ask for those to ask questions where a woman has every right to ask a question
in a right spirit just as a man does. There is a time when we ask for praise
to be offered to God when a woman has every right to praise God just like
anyone else does. That's when the preacher or teacher deflects the
communication responsibility to his congregation and says I want to hear from
you. But that wasn't the issue here. The issue here was interruption. The
issue here was usurpation, that's a different issue.
So, we understand what he's saying. Now let's go back to 1 Corinthians 11
because we can't understand this whole picture without understanding this
passage. By the way, in chapter 14 he says not to do this is absolutely
unthinkable because he says in verse 36, "What came the Word of God out from
you, or came it unto you only." In other words, if you defy this are you
telling us that you're the originator of the Word of God? You're going to
decide how it ought to be done? Or maybe it was just written for you to twist
any way you want...it's ludicrous to him. What? Did you write the Bible, you
who want to exercise authority in the church, you who want to speak out and be
the preachers, teachers and prophesiers and tongue speakers and all that? It's
just ludicrous to imagine that you can overturn the Scripture, that you can do
it any way you want.
And going back to 1 Corinthians chapter 11, verse 2, he says, "I praise
you, brethren, because you remember me in all things and keep the ordinances as
I deliver them to you." I think we often get the idea that everybody in
Corinth was corrupt, but this verse tells us not so, there was a great number
there who were not. And he says I know you remember me in all things and you
do keep the commandments or ordinances the way I delivered them to you. But
there's something you have to know. Now remember, this is Corinth. In the
middle of Corinth was a temple to Aphrodite, a thousand priestess prostitutes
with heads open and exposed and hair cut short flaunting their sexuality trying
to lure men into sexual acts in the temple, put up on the acro of Corinth, the
hilltop outside Corinth, this big temple. And these women again flaunting
their liberation, flaunting their sexuality. There was a whole attitude there
very much like Ephesus. So he says I know you obey me, I know you remember
what I said, but I want to tell you this, folks, you've got to realize the head
of every man is Christ and the head of the woman is the man. And the head of
Christ is God. You have to get one thing straight, women are put in a place of
submission to men. That's just how it is. That's just how it is.
And again I remind you that it's not to say that women can't speak. It's
not to say women can't pray. It is to understand as an attitudinal objective
that the man is the head of the woman. Now look at verse 3 again, nobody
argues about this, the head of every man is Christ. Do you know anybody that
doesn't believe that? Do you know anybody that now has a sort of a Christian's
liberation demanding equality with Christ? Anybody running around saying I
want to be equal with Christ or forget it? No. And everybody understands that
God is the head of Christ. Christ comes in subjection to His Father, becomes a
servant, takes upon Him the form of a servant, humility and all that,
Philippians 2, the kenosis. Then why do we debate about the fact that the
man is the head of the woman? That's just basic.
So, let me give you a little cultural thing. In Corinth, women as a
custom covered their heads. That was how a woman identified her humility,
that's how she hid herself as if to say I am not available, I belong to one
man. And that was her modesty, that was her femininity. This is how she
carried herself and how she clothed herself to demonstrate her womanliness, her
femininity.
In the Corinthian society, men were uncovered. Their heads were bare,
their faces were open and that was the mark of maleness. Somehow in the
Corinthian church these things were getting inverted. And women were praying
and speaking the Word of God with their heads uncovered, actually sort of
identifying with the prostitutes and the woman's liberation movement. And men,
maybe from some Jewish background or something, were covering their heads and
praying and people were looking at them and saying, "They're feministic." So
he says in verse 4, look, every man who prays or prophesies having his head
covered dishonors his head. What are you doing? Don't do that. Why? You
say, "You mean it's a sin to put something on your head when you pray?"
No...not unless your culture perceives that as something that's feminine. And
the point there was for a man to cover himself was to be acting like a woman.
Men didn't do that. Verse 5, "And every woman who prays or prophesies with her
head uncovered dishonors her head and she might as well be like one who is
totally shaved, she might as well destroy all of her femininity, look like a
prostitute or some liberated person." Verse 7, "A man not to have his head covered..." See, in their society
that said something.
So what Paul is saying is this, now listen carefully.
Look at your society and mark out the symbols. What are the symbols of
femininity in our society? What are the symbols of masculinity? And identify
with those. If they don't violate Scripture, if they don't violate God's
design for morality, then adhere to those symbols because that says something
to your society. Listen, even this society today still knows when a woman
looks like a woman. There are symbols in our society for femininity. And you
know as well as I do that you can look at a woman who obviously has adapted the
symbols of femininity and looks like a woman, and you can look at another woman
who looks like she is rebelling against everything that womanhood absolutely
means. Can't you tell that difference? Of course you can because even our
society has symbols. Every society does.
Our society has symbols of maleness. You can look at a man and by the way
he appears and carries himself and dresses, you can say now that guy's a man.
And you can look at another guy and you get the impression that this guy is
really very feminine. Because he's denying the symbols of maleness and he's
communicating an inverted perverted message. So that's all he's saying to the
Corinthians. Look, when you behave yourself as Christians, do so in a way that
adheres to the perception of your culture so they'll understand. And further
on down in verse 10 he says even nature...pardon me, verse 14, even nature has
provided an analogy for the symbol of head coverings by giving faster growing
hair to women as a special covering from God.
So women then are to take a role of submission as the one who is under the
headship of man. Now people say about verse 5, "Well, wait a minute, here are
women praying and prophesying. Isn't that in the church?" Well, it doesn't
say so. Let me show you something. I think he's just talking about general
things. I don't think he's talking about the formal worship of the church, the
coming together of the church. You say, "Why don't you?" Go down to verse 18,
this is really the first time he gets into issues about the church. Look what
it says. "For first of all," what is that again? Literally in the Greek, "In
the first place," which means if this is the first place there isn't any place
before this. If this is first of all, there isn't anything else related to
what he's going to talk about. So, first of all, "When you come together in
the church," may I suggest to you that nobody has come together in the church
until that verse? "First of all, when you come together in the church I want
you to take care of these divisions." So prior to this he hasn't been talking
about the worship of the church. So the women who are permitted to pray or
prophesy with their head covered are not doing that in the church, they're
doing that in other than that duly constituted worshiping place of the church.
He doesn't get to describing the church until verse 18.
So here he is just saying in general, maybe it's in a home fellowship,
maybe it's in a Bible study, maybe it's in a prayer time, maybe it's when you
get together as a family around the table, maybe when it's when several
families get together, when you Christians get together wherever it might be,
you women maintain the decorum of submission. You men maintain the decorum of
headship. And then later on he gets to the church when it comes together in
its formal assembly. So the allowance for a woman to pray and prophesy in
verse 5 does not overturn what Paul says in 1 Timothy. Sure a woman should
pray, of course she should speak forth the Word of God every time she has an
opportunity, but not when given the title of the official teacher or prayer in
behalf of the church when it comes together for worship and certainly not as an
intruder into the worship of the church. This is very important.
So, in verse 13 he says, "Decide for yourselves." Just decide for
yourselves. Take a look at the symbol and make a decision. Is it right that a
woman pray to God uncovered? And you know in your society you're going to say
no. So follow the custom. The sum of what he says is this, if a woman is
veiled when she prays or speaks the Word of God, she attests to her womanhood,
she affirms her role, she reflects her husband's protective covering over her,
she protects the relationship she has with her husband, she doesn't rebel. She
knows heaven is pleased. Verse 10 says even the angels are watching. She is
acknowledging what verses 7 and following say that this is so important. Man
is the image and glory of God and the woman is the glory of man. Boy, that is
a verse that just sends the women's liberation people right up in space.
So man in a sense is the sun and woman is the moon that reflects the light
of the sun. Man is the representative of the glorious dominion and headship of
God, and woman is the representative of that one who follows. The woman is the
glory of man. God could have created them together, could have
said "Man-woman," and they would have been there and He would have said you're
equal, go at it, see who wins. He didn't do that.
Now why do we want to fight that? She was taken out of man. Verse 8,
"The man is not of the woman but the woman of the man." You talk about which
came first the chicken or the egg? The man came first in this case, the man.
"Neither was the man created for the woman but the woman was created for the
man."
Now why do we not want to accept this? Let me tell you what the
underlying philosophy is, very simple. God has designed all of human life in
terms of this key word, "relationships." Okay? Everything is built on
relationships, family, fathers and mothers and children, husbands and wives.
Everybody has a relationship. And within those relationships there are
differing roles. Is that not so? All right. In our culture and our society,
the word is not relationship, the word is individuality. I want my rights. I
want to do my thing. If you fit into my life for a little while, you can come
in. The first time I don't like the way you're doing it, you're gone.
Marriage, divorce, marriage, divorce, live with somebody, whatever it is,
everybody living for himself. The family is being disintegrated, it's just a
bunch of sticks all living side by side. And in a society where relationship
as a concept of life is lost, and it is replaced by individuality, why not
everybody having equal rights and equal roles? You see?
So what does Satan do to undermine the role of a woman, he attacks the
whole concept of family, devastates, destroys the family. And in the
devastation and destruction of the family, all you've got left is a bunch of
individuals who look at the whole world through their own eyes and see only
their own individuality and scream for their rights. That's the whole thing.
Bottom line. But the church is an organism. And the family is an organism.
And the relationships of the family take right into the church that same kind
of attitude. The feminist movement is nothing more than the human race being
defined as a bunch of unrelated individuals all demanding their own rights.
That's Satan's big lie.
Now I'll tell you, to be honest, you may not agree with Paul says. You
may not like what he says. But he said it. And it's obvious what he said.
You say, "Well, now when can women prophesy?" Any time you want to speak
the Word of God, speak it. Any time and any place, but don't try to take over
the church. Don't try to step into a territory where you're not allowed. A
woman can speak the truth. Anna spoke it. Mary when she gave her magnificat
at the announcement at the birth of Christ spoke forth the Word of God and no
one ever more modeled the virtue of womanhood than she. Listen, women, I pray
God that you speak forth the truth over and over again as long as you live.
You say, "Well, what about...what about at a Bible study, can we share what
we see?" Of course, of course. In the right environment when that is given to
you, when the leadership says yes we want to hear from you, share what the
Spirit of God is doing, offer praise to God. Yes. You say, "What about
praying? Can women pray? What if there are men there, can women still pray?"
Look at Acts 1. In Acts chapter 1 we have a prayer meeting. Verse 13, "They
came in, came in to Jerusalem from the Mount of Olives, they went into the
Upper Room and they're abode Peter, James, John, Andrew, Philip and Thomas,
Bartholomew, Matthew, James the son of Alpheus, Simon the Zealot and Judas son
of James." This is what's left after Judas, of course, who is called Iscariot
is gone. Here are the remaining disciples.
Now look at verse 14. "These all continued with one accord in...what?
what were they doing up there?...in prayer and supplication." Watch this,
"With the women and Mary the mother of Jesus and with His brothers." Can women
get together with men and have a prayer meeting? Of course. Here's one right
here and it involved the eleven disciples, a lot of women including Mary and
some other people. In fact, how many were there in that upper room? A hundred
and twenty, weren't there? They had a prayer meeting. There's a time and a
place for a woman to speak forth the Word of God. There's a time and a place
for a woman to pray. There's a time and a place when asked for a woman to
share a question. The point of all of these things is this, you go back to 1
Timothy again and it's very obvious what he means when he says, "Let the women
keep silence," he's talking about in the official meeting together of the
church and he's meaning their silence in the sense that I do not allow a woman
to teach. And what I'll show you next week is that that phrase "a woman to
teach" literally in the Greek should be translated "I do not allow for a woman
teacher as an on-going official office." It's just that that's consistent.
In the Old Testament, no women kings, no women prophets, no women priests.
In the New Testament, no women prophets in the
on-going New Testament sense of the prophet, no women evangelists, no women
pastor-teachers, no women elders. So why are we
concerned when the church goes on with the same pattern that when it comes to
the order of the worship of the church, that responsibility to be the preacher,
the teacher, the one who speaks for God, the one who leads in prayer as we saw
in verse 8 where he says I command that the men pray, the one who leads the
congregation before the throne of God, this is a role given to men.
You say, "Well now why would God give all the good stuff to men and leave
us women just sitting here listening in silence?" You want to know something?
We have the easy part. You say, "Well, where's the balance?" Come next week.
It's exactly what I'm going to get to and that's what I wanted to get to today
but I couldn't get there. I just can't go fast enough. Let's bow in prayer.
Father, how thankful we are, how thankful we are for Your Word. How
thankful we are for its clarity. We understand what You ask of us as men and
women. Help us, Lord, not to be looking for the toothpick in somebody else's
eye, but we've taken the two-by-four out of our own eye. Help me as a man and
the rest of the men of this congregation not to be faulting the women until
we've become the head that we should be. Help us not to be criticizing others
until we've examined our own hearts. And if we are the head of the woman as
Christ is the head of us and God is the head of Christ, then help us to act in
a way consistent with that. Father, may the men of this church be men as men
ought to be, giving spiritual leadership and direction, taking responsibility
for support, nourishing and cherishing their wives, protecting and saving and
delivering them from harm and danger, encouraging and supporting and
strengthening them in their spiritual life. And, Lord, may the women be women.
May they bear all the grace and loveliness and beauty of womanhood. May they
enjoy all the spiritual privilege, promise, blessing and instruction. May they
be on the front lines in prayer, on the front lines in speaking forth the word
of truth and understand that in that role that is designed for them there is
complete fulfillment.
We thank You that You've given to the church teachers, men, godly men, who
can stand in the place of Christ as His representatives, bearing His glory
before the congregation. We pray that we might always be faithful to that
design, that we might see that the place of men is in the overt leadership of
the church, the teaching, preaching, praying, decision making, ruling authority
of the church. And that the role of the women is to learn everything they can
and come alongside in submission so that they can be prepared for that
immeasurably profound and far- reaching task that is theirs within in the home,
as we shall see in our next time together. And, Lord, may the combination of
the men who lead in the church and the women who powerfully profoundly and for
life influence in the home build a godly seed for the praise and glory of the
Savior in the generations to come.
© 1997 Grace to You