CONTRADICTION, PRINCIPLE OF (principium contradictionis)

This article appears in Volume V07, Page 40 of the Encyclopedia Britannica.

Encyclopedia Britannica - Main :: COM-COR

CONTRADICTION, PRINCIPLE OF (principium contradictionis) , in logic, the

term

TERM

applied to the second of the three primary "

laws

LAWS

of thought." The oldest statement of the law is that contradictory statements cannot both at the same time be true, e.g. the two propositions " A is B " and " A is not B" are mutually exclusive. A may be B at one time, and not at another; A may be partly B and partly not B at the same time; but it is impossible to predicate of the same thing, at the same time, and in the same sense, the

absence

ABSENCE (Lat. absentia)

and the presence of the same quality. This is the statement of the law given by

Aristotle

ARISTOTLE
ARISTOTLE (384-322 B.C.)

(TO yap afire inraPXEw TE Kai i) irrrapXEIV abbac roV nil' ai)rcli Kai Kara TO airrb, Metaph. P 3, 1005 b 19). It takes no account of the truth of either proposition; if one is true, the other is not; one of the two must be true.

Modern

MODERN

logicians, following

Leibnitz

LEIBNITZ (LEIBNIZ), GOTTFRIED WILHELM

and Kant, have generally adopted a different statement, by which the law assumes an essentially different meaning. Their

formula

FORMULA
FORMULA (Lat. diminutive of forma, shape,
pattern
- PATTERN
, &c., especially used of rules of judicial
procedure
- PROCEDURE (Fr. procedure, from Lat. procedere, to go for-ward)
)

is " A is not not-A "; in other words it is impossible to predicate of a thing a quality which is its contradictory. Unlike

Aristotle

ARISTOTLE
ARISTOTLE (384-322 B.C.)

's law this law deals with the necessary relation between subject and predicate in a single judgment. Whereas Aristotle states that one or other of two contradictory propositions must be false, the Kantian law states that a particular kind of proposition is in itself necessarily false. On the other hand there is a real connexion between the two

laws

LAWS

. The denial of the statement " A is not-A" presupposes some knowledge of what A is, i.e. the statement A is A. In other words a judgment about A is implied. Kant's analytical propositions depend on presupposed concepts which are the same for all

people

PEOPLE

. His statement, regarded as a logical principle purely and apart from material facts, does not therefore amount to more than that of Aristotle, which deals simply with the significance of negation.
See text-books of Logic, e.g. C. Sigwart's Logic (trans. Helen Dendy, London, 1895), vol. i. pp. 142 fell. ; for the various expressions of the law see Ueberweg's Logik, 77; also J. S. Mill, Examination of Hamilton, 471; Venn, Empirical Logic.

End of Article: CONTRADICTION, PRINCIPLE OF (principium contradictionis)

If you wish, you can link directly to this article.

<a href="http://jcsm.org/StudyCenter/Encyclopedia/COM_COR/CONTRADICTION_PRINCIPLE_OF_pri.html">
CONTRADICTION, PRINCIPLE OF (principium contrad...
</a>

(Previous)
CONTRACTILE VACUOLE

(Next)
CONTRAFAGOTTO, DOUBLE

JCSM was founded in 1997 and exists to help the community and bring people into a life-changing and productive relationship with Jesus Christ. JCSM offers over 200,000 free web pages, including its weekly inspirational emails that were sent continuously for over a decade.

Jesus Christ Saves Ministries
P.O. Box 9297
San Diego, CA 92169
1-888-887-0417 or Email